Drivetrain loss calculations ...

Discussion in 'Non Technical' started by RedZedMikey, Jan 18, 2006.

  1. RedZedMikey

    RedZedMikey RZM should now be DZM

    Motor magazine's December 2005 issue had an interesting article in which they did a pretty serious comparo between HSV Clubbie R8, Scoobie MY06 STI and a Misterbitchy Evo IX.

    As well as doing the usual dragstrip and circuit runs, they also did power runs on a dyno, which is pretty unusual for a car mag - all they ususally quote is flywheel power figures. This has resulted in a fairly reasonable estimate of drivetrain losses that can be calculated.

    These are all factory stock cars, so (with a grain of salt) we'll accept the quoted power figures in this calculation - and all 3 cars were manuals, so this theory cannot be extrapolated to auto slushboxes :p.

    CLUBSPORT R8: 297kw @ flywheel; 235rwkw = 62kw difference = 20.9% loss.
    MY06 STI: 206kw @ flywheel; 157rwkw = 49kw difference = 23.8% loss.
    EVO IX: 206kw @ flywheel; 159rwkw = 47kw difference = 22.8% loss.

    CLUBSPORT R8: 5.53 0-100kmh; ¼ mile in 13.70 @ 174kmh; Oran Sth in 51.75 secs.
    MY06 STI: 5.43 0-100kmh; ¼ mile in 13.48 @ 166kmh; Oran Sth in 49.45 secs.
    EVO IX: 5.02 0-100kmh; ¼ mile in 13.32 @ 169kmh; Oran Sth in 49.75 secs.

    So if I now throw my Z into the comparison, everything seems to fit. My last dyno run was 207rwkw. If I apply a 23% drivetrain loss based on the magazines's results I get 269 flywheel kw, which slots in nicely. Comparing the drag strip times my best of 13.62 @ 170 seems to fit nicely and make sense of the figures.

    So, for the future, I will divide the rwkw figure by 0.77 to get an approximate calculation of flywheel kw, and I won't expect to beat a new STI or Evo IX until i'm running a bit more than 12lb boost!

    Aaaaaaah the things you have time to think about when you're away on holiday!
     

Share This Page