Neutral Switch?

Discussion in 'Technical' started by B-Line, Jul 27, 2015.

  1. B-Line

    B-Line Older junior member

    I have a 5 speed manual, the sensors on the rear drivers side are a bit of a puzzle, in particular the one at the rear & high up, from the manual it looks like its the neutral switch, at some stage this has been disconnected at the plug, I cannot for the life of me find another harness anywhere where it should plug into, the sensor below and just forward of it has had a new pair of wires run down to it from up the firewall somewhere, I guess the questions are a. where would the original harness run from? & b. what effect will not having the neutral switch in the system have on the car?
     
  2. East Coast Z

    East Coast Z Well-Known Member

    Was this one of those automatic to manual conversions?
    The VIN plate will tell you.
     
  3. WazTTed

    WazTTed Grease Monkey

    if yours is a manual you can bypass the neutral switch or else it will mess with your idle timing !
     
  4. Kane_Z32

    Kane_Z32 New Member

    Original harness will accompany the starter motor wiring.
     
  5. B-Line

    B-Line Older junior member

    Its a factory manual
     
  6. MikeZ32

    MikeZ32 das Über member

    so just cut the wire?
     
  7. WazTTed

    WazTTed Grease Monkey

    ground it in the engine bay :)

    you have 2 cut the yellow with blue wire, insulate the end closest 2 the battery and ground the other end of the wire that goes into the connector.. check with datascan and your neutral switch should now be off..
     
  8. MikeZ32

    MikeZ32 das Über member

    My trans is out at the moment. Could I just ground the connector wire on the trans or does it have to be done at the engine bay end?

    Was thinking for ease just cut the wire at the sensor (so I'm sure to get the right wire) ground that correct wire by sandwiching it between the sensor and the trans body.
     
  9. WazTTed

    WazTTed Grease Monkey

    you ground the wire in the engine bay as it effects the ecu . i have a auto harness on mine so it was never connected. if its not connected the ecu always thinks its in neutral and pushes the timing to 25 !!
     
  10. B-Line

    B-Line Older junior member

    Would I be right in thinking that this is why my idle always seems to be all over the place?, e.g. when I pull up at the lights it and I have the clutch in it goes to 1500 then slowly settles down to 800 ish,
     
  11. WazTTed

    WazTTed Grease Monkey

    could be man, hunting that much usually has something to do with where you have your base idle set tho
     
  12. B-Line

    B-Line Older junior member

    Neutral switch again

    OK guy's an update and a call for help, I have figured out that half of my idle issue was a bad temp sensor connection,

    I have managed to pick up an old conzult cable and my timing is rock steady on 20 deg, so what I am thinking is that because my neutral switch has been disconnected it does not adjust timing at all (Me being an old style non professional part time mechanic) at least that is what I have come up with,

    now it seems from what I have read ,I have two options,either reconnect the neutral switch OR short out the wiring at the other end, now my problem is exactly where I do I physically find the wiring, can anybody point me in the right direction? I forgot to mention I am also thinking that this is also causing my speed sensitive steering to not work,

    If I am reading right when the ECU does not pick up the switch signal after 10 seconds it will turn the steering onto the hard setting,so another question is , if I do manage to short out the wires what effect will that have on the steering?
     
    Last edited: Oct 27, 2015
  13. syntax_X

    syntax_X Zed Head

  14. B-Line

    B-Line Older junior member

  15. Fists

    Fists Well-Known Member

  16. jamersss

    jamersss Member

    pin 44 is at/mt neutral - linky.

    While we are on this topic my car is a TT manual conversion.

    Currently the neutral switch is not connected to anything and my idle sits at 25 deg on the timing light. I'd like to put the neutral switch to use.

    If I were to connect pin 44 to one wire on the neutral switch and earth the second wire on the neutral switch, would this be a workable solution?

    I'm not an auto elec but in theory I think this might work.
     
  17. syntax_X

    syntax_X Zed Head

    Its not broken
     
  18. SuperZ

    SuperZ Resident Z lunatic

    In the middle of my conversion right now

    That is exactly what I intend to do ;)

    Cannot see why this would not work..............


    Bit confusing on the manual switch from some of the posts - my understanding here is that:

    The auto neutral switch affects timing to allow for the differences of pushing extra toque to maintain idle in drive as opposed to idle out of gear ( timing changes 25 to 15 degrees)

    The manual neutral switch does not affect timing but possibly prevents you from starting in gear with clutch out and is probably why some people state they cannot start the car when this is disconnected ??????

    I am only assuming this, because I cannot see why the engine timing would change on a manual box in gear or out of gear......... and the switch is only either on or off on both types

    Is this right or wrong..............?



    JC


    :zlove:
     
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2015
  19. SuperZ

    SuperZ Resident Z lunatic

    I am also led to believe that if you have nistune - you can change the timing settings to 15 degrees and hence the neutral switch becomes somewhat irrelevant if you do it that way......(circuit can be left open altogether or remain connected)

    Is this right or wrong................
     
  20. ltd

    ltd Linux Ninja

    Other uses for Neutral switch on MT

    I've not seen anyone mention this before so thought I would mention it;

    Since I've not personally analysed the code in the stock ECU I can't confirm however I would highly suspect that the ECU uses the neutral switch to determine when to go in to closed loop idle control (even on a MT).

    With the neutral switch closed, the ECU knows for sure that the car isn't being driven and it should be controlling the idle appropriately.

    On the aftermarket ECU I use (Adaptronic) the neutral/clutch switch is the preferred method to use to trigger this condition.

    I know my neutral switch wasn't working properly and sometimes the car would stall when pulling up to a stop in neutral. I believe this to be related to the lack of the neutral switch as it also does it with the aftermarket ECU without the neutral switch trigger enabled.

    ltd

     

Share This Page